Conducting a Workplace Harassment Investigation: Employer Responsibilities and Liability Risks

Workplace harassment is a serious issue that employers must address promptly and effectively. Employers have a legal and ethical duty to investigate allegations of harassment to ensure a safe and non-hostile work environment. Failing to conduct a proper investigation can lead to legal liability, reputational damage, and employee dissatisfaction. 

Steps for Conducting a Workplace Harassment Investigation 

Initiate the Investigation Promptly 

• The employer should immediately begin an investigation upon receiving a harassment complaint. 

• Delaying the process can escalate the issue and increase the risk of legal liability. 

Assign a Neutral Investigator 

• The investigator should be a neutral party, such as: 

• An HR professional. 

• An external consultant or attorney (if impartiality is a concern). 

• A senior manager not involved in the dispute. 

• The investigator must remain objective, discreet, and thorough throughout the process. 

Gather and Review Relevant Policies and Records 

• Examine the company’s anti-harassment policies and employee handbook for guidance. 

• Review any previous complaints or disciplinary actions related to the alleged harasser. 

Interview the Complainant (Victim) 

• Conduct a private and confidential interview with the employee who reported the harassment. 

• Ask: 

• What happened? 

• When and where did the harassment occur? 

• Who was involved? 

• Were there any witnesses? 

• Have there been previous incidents? 

• How has the harassment affected your work? 

Interview the Alleged Harasser 

• Inform the accused employee of the allegations without assuming guilt. 

• Provide an opportunity for them to explain their side of the story. 

• Ask: 

• What is your relationship with the complainant? 

• Can you describe the incidents in question? 

• Do you have any evidence or witnesses to support your response? 

Interview Witnesses 

• Speak to any employees who may have witnessed the harassment or have relevant information. 

• Witnesses should be encouraged to provide truthful accounts without fear of retaliation. 

Collect and Preserve Evidence 

• Gather supporting documents, such as: 

• Emails, text messages, or other communications. 

• Security footage, if available. 

• Personnel records that may show prior complaints or disciplinary actions. 

Maintain Confidentiality 

• Only discuss the matter with individuals directly involved in the investigation. 

• Inform employees that retaliation against any party involved is strictly prohibited. 

Analyze Findings and Determine Appropriate Action 

• Evaluate all gathered evidence to determine if the complaint is substantiated, unsubstantiated, or inconclusive. 

• Consider actions such as: 

• Disciplinary action (e.g., warnings, suspension, termination). 

• Training or mediation to prevent future issues. 

• Policy changes if workplace conditions contributed to the harassment. 

Document the Investigation and Resolution 

• Keep a detailed written record of the investigation, including: 

• Complaint details. 

• Interviews conducted. 

• Evidence reviewed. 

• Actions taken and rationale. 

• Retain these records for legal and compliance purposes. 

Communicate the Outcome to Involved Parties 

• Inform the complainant and the alleged harasser of the investigation’s conclusion. 

• If corrective action is taken, ensure the complainant feels safe and supported. 

Who Should the Employer Speak To? 

The employer should interview: 

The Complainant – To understand the nature of the allegations. 

The Alleged Harasser – To gather their response and any counterclaims. 

Witnesses – Co-workers, supervisors, or others who may have seen or heard the harassment. 

Relevant Third Parties – Individuals outside the workplace if they have relevant information (e.g., clients, vendors). 

HR Representatives or Supervisors – If they have prior knowledge of related incidents. 

Liability Risks for Failing to Properly Investigate Harassment 

If an employer fails to properly investigate harassment allegations, they may face significant legal, financial, and reputational consequences. 

Legal Liability 

• Violating Employment Laws 

• Title VII of the Civil Rights Act 

• Failing to investigate could lead to lawsuits for negligence or discrimination. 

• Hostile Work Environment Claims 

• If harassment continues due to inaction, employees may file a hostile work environment lawsuit. 

• Courts may hold the employer liable for failing to protect employees. 

• Retaliation Lawsuits 

• Employees are protected from retaliation for reporting harassment. 

• If an employer fires, demotes, or mistreats a complainant after they report harassment, they may face additional legal penalties. 

Financial Liability 

• Litigation Costs 

• A harassment lawsuit can lead to legal fees, settlements, and court-ordered damages. 

• Government Fines and Penalties 

• Regulatory agencies (e.g., Equal Employment Opportunity Commission – EEOC) may fine companies for failing to investigate harassment complaints. 

• Loss of Productivity 

• Unaddressed harassment can lead to low morale, absenteeism, and high employee turnover, reducing workplace efficiency. 

Reputational Damage 

• Bad Publicity 

• If harassment cases become public, the employer may suffer public backlash. 

• Loss of Talent 

• Skilled employees may leave if they feel unsafe or unsupported. 

• Impact on Business Partnerships 

• Vendors, clients, or investors may cut ties if the company is known for ignoring workplace harassment. 

Preventing Harassment and Ensuring Proper Investigations 

To reduce liability risks and create a safe work environment, employers should: 

Establish a Clear Anti-Harassment Policy 

• Clearly define what constitutes harassment and the process for reporting complaints. 

• Provide examples of prohibited behavior (e.g., sexual harassment, bullying, discriminatory remarks). 

Train Employees and Managers 

• Conduct regular workplace harassment training for all employees. 

• Ensure managers understand how to properly handle complaints. 

Encourage a Speak-Up Culture 

• Promote an environment where employees feel safe reporting harassment. 

• Assure employees that all complaints will be taken seriously and investigated confidentially. 

Implement a Strong Investigation Process 

• Follow consistent investigation procedures for every harassment claim. 

• Ensure independent oversight to prevent bias or cover-ups. 

Conclusion 

Workplace harassment investigations must be conducted thoroughly, promptly, and fairly to protect both employees and employers. A proper investigation ensures that complaints are taken seriously, helps prevent legal liability, and promotes a safe and professional work environment. 

By following clear investigation procedures, interviewing all relevant parties, and documenting findings, employers can mitigate risks and uphold a workplace free of harassment. Ignoring or mishandling allegations, on the other hand, can result in lawsuits, financial penalties, and long-term reputational damage. 

Employers must prioritize proactive measures, strong policies, and fair investigations to create a harassment-free and legally compliant workplace.  

 

About Us
Oberman Law Firm represents clients in a wide range of practice areas, including private equity, M&A, healthcare, corporate transactions, intellectual property, data privacy and security, regulatory compliance and governance, cross-border transactions, labor and employment, construction law, litigation, private clients’ services, corporate restructuring, and white-collar and governmental disputes.

As a firm, we offer the highest quality legal advice coupled with extraordinary and tailored service to deliver exceptional results to our clients. Our philosophy is to invest deeply in the brightest legal talent and build dynamic teams that operate at the pinnacle of respective practice areas. We believe in empowering our attorneys, encouraging entrepreneurialism, operating ethically and with integrity, and collaborating to bring the very best to every client engagement. These principles have guided us in building extraordinary and successful long-term partnerships with our clients.