Why Business Partners Must Have Deadlock and Exit Provisions That Work or Else

Why Business Partners Mus…
KEY TAKEAWAYS
  • Businesses with two equal owners, or evenly divided voting blocs, are especially vulnerable to deadlock that can paralyze operations.
  • Effective agreements build in a sequence of steps: escalation, mediation, a tie-breaker or arbitration, and, as a last resort, a buyout mechanism.
  • Buy-sell tools such as put and call rights and “shotgun” provisions can resolve a deadlock, but only when they are drafted with the owners’ finances in mind.
  • Without these provisions, owners may be left with litigation, including claims for judicial dissolution, which is expensive, slow, and public.

Most business partnerships begin with shared goals and trust. Over time, owners’ priorities naturally diverge. One wants to reinvest while the other wants distributions. One wants to expand while the other is ready to retire. One is working full time in the business while the other is not. None of these differences are unusual, but without a mechanism to resolve them, they can bring a business to a standstill.

The best time to agree on how disagreements will be resolved is before there is one. This article outlines the tools available and how to choose among them.

Why Deadlock Is So Damaging

When owners with equal votes cannot agree on a major decision, such as approving a budget, signing a major contract, admitting a new owner, or selling the business, the business may be unable to act at all. Employees, lenders, and customers notice. Opportunities are lost. And the dispute often spills over into accusations about compensation, expenses, and breaches of fiduciary duty.

If the agreement does not provide a path forward, the owners may end up in court. In most states a court may, in certain circumstances, order the dissolution of an LLC when it is not reasonably practicable to carry on the business in conformity with its operating agreement. Litigation of this kind is costly and unpredictable, and it can destroy the value the owners spent years building.

Step One: Escalation and Mediation

Many disputes can be resolved when owners are required to slow down and talk. A well-drafted agreement can require a structured meeting of the owners within a set number of days after a deadlock is declared, followed by mediation with a neutral mediator if the meeting fails. Mediation is confidential, relatively inexpensive, and preserves the owners’ control over the outcome.

Step Two: A Tie-Breaker or Arbitration

If mediation fails, the agreement can direct the dispute to a decision-maker:

  • Independent director or manager: A trusted outside advisor with a tie-breaking vote on defined categories of decisions.
  • Expert determination: For technical disputes, such as valuation or accounting questions, a qualified expert can make a binding decision.
  • Arbitration: A private, generally faster alternative to litigation that keeps disputes out of the public court record.

Step Three: Buyout Mechanisms

When owners fundamentally can no longer work together, the cleanest solution is often for one to buy out the other. Common mechanisms include:

  • Put and call rights: An owner may require the others to buy (a put), or the others may require an owner to sell (a call), at a price determined by an agreed method.
  • “Shotgun” or buy-sell offer: One owner names a price; the other must either sell at that price or buy at that price. This encourages fair offers, but it can favor the owner with greater access to capital.
  • Sealed-bid or auction procedures: Owners submit competing bids, and the highest bidder buys the business.
  • Forced sale of the company: As a last resort, the agreement may require the business to be marketed and sold to a third party.

The right mechanism depends on the owners’ relative financial positions, their roles in the business, and whether either could realistically run the company alone.

Related Provisions Worth Reviewing

  • Clear definitions of which decisions require unanimous or supermajority approval
  • Owner compensation, expense reimbursement, and distribution policies, which are frequent sources of conflict
  • Removal of an owner for cause, with a clear definition of “cause”
  • Non-competition and non-solicitation obligations that apply after a buyout
  • Confidentiality of disputes and prohibitions on disparagement

Conclusion

Disagreement among owners is not a sign of failure; it is a normal part of running a business over many years. What separates an orderly resolution from a destructive dispute is usually the quality of the provisions the owners agreed to in advance.

Owners who build in escalation steps, a fair decision-maker, and a workable exit path protect not only themselves, but also their employees, customers, and the value of the business.

How Oberman Law Firm Can Help

Oberman Law Firm helps business owners design governance, deadlock, and exit provisions tailored to their ownership structure. We review existing operating, partnership, and shareholder agreements; draft escalation, mediation, arbitration, and buy-sell provisions; and, when disputes arise, counsel owners on practical paths to resolution that protect the value of the business.

TAKE THE NEXT STEP

Make sure your agreement has a plan for disagreement before you need one. Request a review of your deadlock and exit provisions.

Request an agreement review: obermanlaw.com/business-law

Oberman Law Firm provides this material for informational purposes only. The use of a lawyer is an important decision and should not be based solely upon advertisements.

Categories: Blogs, Business, Insights